By Susan Wroble
In the post-conference survey from last years’ Rocky Mountain Chapter SCBWI’s annual conference, there was one request that really stuck with me. The attendee wrote “I want to learn how more about reviews. How to write them. How to get them.”
This resonated because I had struggled with reviews. While there are many reasons I now write them (learning the market, supporting my writing community, introducing people to books I love…), there is also the hope that one day, others will be writing reviews for me. Writing reviews feels a bit like dipping into karma.
I post most of my reviews on Amazon or Instagram, but Goodreads and Barnes and Noble are both great options, along with podcasts. While Amazon isn’t where I tend to buy new books, it is a place where numbers matter, and one of my goals is to make my reviews as effective as possible for book creators.
My process is fairly simple: I log into Amazon, search for the book I plan to review, then scroll down until I get to “write a customer review.” I give a short paragraph about why I loved the book. If it’s a picture book, I try to include a photo of an interior page, as well as a bit about the artwork—here’s an example with Patty Cisneros Prevo’s book TENACIOUS. I only write reviews for books that I can honestly and happily rate as five stars.
I’ve found that Instagram is a fabulous place to post reviews of books that I want to be able to find and reference easily later on—perhaps as mentor texts, like Roxanne Troup’s compare/contrast structure in MY GRANDPA, MY TREE AND ME, or as comp titles for a work-in-progress.
Taking it to the Next Level:
I’m always in awe of those people who have taken reviewing to the next level. I’d encourage you to take the time to read, follow and get to know these incredible reviewers, their sites, and their reviews and resources.
Bianca Schultz is founder and editor of The Children’s Book Review (TCBR). The Association for Library Service to Children (ALSC) has named TCBR one of the Great Websites for Kids. And no wonder—this amazingly user-friendly site provides lists by author, subject, age, and favorites (including board books, books on activism and diverse and inclusive books). And if that weren’t all, there’s the Growing Reader’s podcast, frequent book give-aways, interviews with authors and illustrators, and a rich trove of articles and writing resources, including this one on the art of getting your children’s book reviewed!
Children’s book expert Melissa Taylor operates the site Imagination Soup. More than 35,000 teachers, parents and librarians subscribe to the Imagination Soup newsletter. Her newsletters give book reviews and learning resources, and the highly searchable site gives books by genre, age and—my favorite as a former homeschooler—playful learning. Being included on Melissa’s incredible booklists provides a lot of exposure. Imagination Soup is a go-to site for lists — say you want a list of books to teach word choice, books in a series by grade-level, exceptional books with autistic characters… just about every possible list you could imagine is on this site! For reviews, Melissa includes a short paragraph about the book and a purchasing link.
If you write middle grade, Greg Pattridge is your guy! Greg runs the “Always in the Middle” site. His reviews provide a summary of the book, the book birthday and page count, “Five More Things to Like” and a bit about the author (and illustrator, when applicable). Greg has a great break-down by category, so if you are looking for MG graphic novels, or nonfiction, or sci-fi, for example, his site is an excellent place to search.
Greg lend his support to other middle grade reviewers with his Marvelous Middle Grade Mondays (MMGM) posts, where he links to several other middle grade review sites — and he makes it super easy to be included. To have your review of a MG book included in the MMGM line-up, all you have to do is email Greg at gpcolo (at) gmail (dot) com by Sunday night with a link to your blog and the title you are featuring, MMGM in the subject line, then schedule a post for a Monday.
Author and reading specialist Laura Roettiger doesn’t do traditional book reviews. Instead, each month she features one author or illustrator and their book on her blog. I was honored to be highlighted in November 2022. Laura’s process is that she sends her interviewees a list of questions and requests a photos to accompany the post. I can tell you that, from an author’s perspective, having an interview like this to be able to link to is a true gift.
So for those of you wondering how to start reviewing, there is no “right” way. Just start, and over time you’ll figure out what works for you! And if you are wondering how to get reviews, that’s easy. Lean into the karma of supporting your kidlit community, and gift them reviews.




